An animal lover who hunts and kills her holiday turkey

My Christmas dinner was up in one of those trees. It was snowing lightly on a minus-two-degree dawn, and I was lying on my belly bundled in white camo, pointing the muzzle of a Benelli 12-gauge through a cluster of fireweed.

The cold hurt my hands in a way I wondered if I should worry about. In front of me, a snow-coated field stretched for 500 yards to a line of bare trees silhouetted against a blush of sunrise. The trees’ branches were dotted with roosting turkeys, and their occasional gobbles carried back across the field to where I waited, breathing into my face mask.

Next to me, rising on his knees to better see the birds, was Brent Lawrence, a friend who worked for the National Wild Turkey Federation, a nonprofit conservation group. We were hunting together outside the town of Kearney, Nebraska, for three days in December — one of which had already passed.

Now he tapped my shoulder and pointed: The dots had started flapping to the ground, and single-file lines of birds were bobbing into the field, their chatter echoing in the cold air. I took a deep breath and adjusted my grip on the gun.

I’d started hunting a few years before, shocking everyone who knew me…My reformative logic went like this: For every turkey wrap or club sandwich I’d ever eaten, something had been killed for my benefit — I’d just never done the killing myself. The deer hunt invitation seemed an opportunity, a challenge even, to reclaim my place in the food chain by assuming responsibility for the meat on my plate…

Gradually the turkeys spread out, and one wandered a little closer to us. It pecked at the ground, then raised its head and stood perfectly still for one moment. I squeezed the trigger.

The blast of the gun is always a bit of a surprise — more like something that happens to me than something I initiate. All at once, my ears were ringing, the turkey was thrashing in the snow, and Brent and I were racing down the hill toward it.

“Don’t worry; it’s dead,” he shouted. Though its wings were flapping, its head was limp on the ground. I wanted to look away but didn’t — this was part of my responsibility.

RTFA. Read the whole article.

I think anyone who’s hunted has wandered through the same maze of ethic and emotion. This is a serious piece of existential reflection whether you hunt or not, eat like a typical omnivore or restrictive vegan.

Enjoyable writing and reading from someone worth reading.

4 thoughts on “An animal lover who hunts and kills her holiday turkey

  1. Morey says:

    For every turkey wrap or club sandwich I’d ever eaten, something had been killed for my benefit — I’d just never done the killing myself.

    For me, this sums up the matter. If you do the hunting, at least you have the benefit of knowing that the animal lived a normal life.. up to the point that you stuck your big nose in, anyway.

    As an animal lover, I am aware, all the time, of the conflict– maybe irreconcilable– between my love of animals and my taste for meat. But I stop short, way short, of apologizing for my biology. I didn’t make me. It’s hard to argue that it is unnatural to eat meat.

    Though.. as Ivonne points out.. there are alternatives. Those of us who perceive a conflict should at least think about it.

    How about AFTER I go out for some chicken?

  2. doris grossman says:

    This hypocrite is an evil, blood-thirsty ghoul. You cannot be an “animal lover” and hunt. I hope she chokes on her meal.
    If she’d substitute her prey for her children’s names, she might have a clue about how wrong what she’s done is. Otherwise, she’s just too stupid to understand love of animals.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.