Interested in directly uploading books to your brain?

❝ What if humans could upload all the great classics of literature to their brains, without having to go through the arduous process of reading? Wonderful and leveling as that may seem, it’s a prospect that I’m not sure we should readily embrace.

❝ A while ago, I listened to an interview with futurist Ray Kurzweil on astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson’s radio show StarTalk. Kurzweil described…how our brains might someday interface directly with non-biological forms of intelligence, possibly with the help of nano-bots that travel through our capillaries.

Given how much faster this interface would be than regular reading, he went on, we’d be able to consume novels like “The Brothers Karamazov” in moments, rather than the current rather clumsy form of ingestion known as reading, which, he said, “could take months.”

❝ At this point Tyson interjected: Are you saying we could just upload “War and Peace”? Yes, Kurzweil answered: “We will connect to neocortical hierarchies in cloud with pre-loaded knowledge.”

This snippet of conversation has baffled and fascinated me ever since. I confess that I do not know a lick about neuroscience. But just knowing something about reading makes the above story implausible, if not alarming.

❝ I’m not sure what Kurzweil thinks when he says our computer minds won’t need to bother to read the book, and I want to give him and his other futurist computer-brain friends some credit. They surely mean more than having the text of the book itself available to us, or even memorized. That wouldn’t represent knowledge. It must be something deeper, a representation of the book possibly as a narrative, or maybe a movie. But again, if we have access only to that movie, it doesn’t represent the same learning that would come through reading and experiencing the book.

A conclusion that is neither correct or incorrect – because, so far, there is no result, no product, to evaluate.

Finally, there’s the possibility that the book’s true meaning would change depending on the state of my brain — that the interface would look into my mind, see and understand my patience with hypocrisy and spiritual conflict, and then transform the story accordingly. In which case, every time I uploaded that book or any other, I’d experience a different story. I doubt this is possible, and in any case I would find the lack of active participation creepy. That said, I’d definitely pay a monthly subscription to try it out.

Disclaimer: I think Ray Kurzweil rocks. In the case of his ventures with Stevie Wonder, that is a literal opinion. IMHO, he makes folks think about new things in new ways and that is invaluable. And, yes, I accept as obvious that outlandish changes confronting 21st Century minds will no doubt be experimented with, evaluated sooner or later.

If an inquiring, well-educated mind finds interest in a process which might increase our capacity to enjoy live and create – as the capability to experiment and decide happens, so will the experiments. Might be fun. Or more.

2 thoughts on “Interested in directly uploading books to your brain?

  1. Steve Ruis says:

    This is a stupid idea. Consider any book you have read. What parts of it can you remember … if any? Not much, I suggest. Maybe the gist of it. The people who quote books all of the time are not quoting books as much as quoting memorized quotes. (Next time somebody quotes a book, ask them what the sentence prior was.) Reliance on memory, therefore, would be futile. If, we have available to us chip memory in an implant, how would we access that material? I suspect it would be much like “books on tape” or other recorded voice books. This means the amount of time saved “reading” it would be zero at best.

    The only way this makes any sense at all is to also have our minds interfaced with an AI that can process such “data” at speed, but then there is no pleasure associated with the reading as you would have the equivalent system to Goggling excerpts. Human minds would ask their AIs things like, “What did Character X say when Character Y shot he dog?” and the response would show instantly. But why then download the book into onboard memory when it could be accessed via Internet?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.